
Based on a real dispatch call: Report of dog taking donkey from property, Peachtree St, Hickory Grove, SC, 12:20 PM EST, Sunday, Nov 1, 2026.
Nobody on Peachtree Street ever figured out who opened the gate. Lulabelle’s money was on the donkey.
Lulabelle was a dog of uncertain ancestry and very certain opinions. She belonged to nobody in particular and to the Hickory Grove Volunteer Fire Department in general. She had been sleeping under their bay doors since the spring the department bought a new pumper truck and she decided it was hers. Every morning she patrolled Peachtree Street from the Baptist church to the four-way stop, collecting sausage biscuits from the people who loved her and dirty looks from the people who didn’t. Her route was a good one, and she had no plans to change it.
Then, on the Sunday after Halloween, she met Clarence.
Clarence was a gray donkey, roughly the size of a recliner and twice as stubborn. He lived behind a split-rail fence at the end of Peachtree, on the property of Miss Odessa Pruitt, who was eighty-one, had buried two husbands, and said she would bury a third “if one would hold still long enough.” She had bought Clarence at a livestock auction in Gaffney for forty dollars. She hadn’t meant to. She had raised her hand to swat a wasp.
Clarence had never once left his pasture in four years. He wasn’t the type. He was the type to stand perfectly still in the middle of the field and stare at the road with the face of a man who has seen how the world works and wants a refund.
Lulabelle had walked past that fence three hundred times. On that particular Sunday she stopped, because the gate was hanging open and Clarence was standing in it, looking out at Peachtree Street the way a person looks at the ocean.
They regarded each other.
Clarence’s lead rope was dangling from his halter, red, frayed at the end, about six feet long. Lulabelle looked at the rope. Clarence looked at Lulabelle. Something unspoken passed between them, the kind of understanding that happens when two creatures who are both done being told where to stand recognize each other.
Lulabelle picked up the rope.
Clarence took a step.
That was it. That was the whole heist.
At 12:20 p.m., Dwayne Kittle of 114 Peachtree Street was mowing his front strip in defiance of both the Sabbath and his wife. He looked up and saw a dog leading a donkey down the center line of the road, at a steady, businesslike walk, like two coworkers heading to lunch.
He turned off the mower. He watched them pass. The donkey looked at him. Dwayne would later say the donkey looked at him “like I owed him money.”
Dwayne called the sheriff’s office non-emergency line, because he was a reasonable man.
“I want to report,” he said, and then stopped, because he heard how it was going to sound.
“Sir?”
“A dog is taking a donkey.”
“Taking it where, sir?”
Dwayne watched them reach the corner and make a confident left. “Toward the Dollar General.”
The dispatcher, a woman named Trina who had worked nineteen years of York County Sunday shifts and believed she’d heard everything, typed REPORT OF DOG TAKING DONKEY FROM PROPERTY into the system. Then she sat back and looked at it for a while, the way you look at a painting.
Deputy Colt Ramsey got the call while he was eating a gas station hot dog in the church parking lot. He was twenty-four and eight months into the job. He had been hoping, the way young deputies do, for something important, like a car chase or a burglary in progress. What he had gotten so far was mostly people’s goats.
“Dog taking a donkey,” Trina said over the radio.
“Copy,” said Colt. Then: “Who’s driving?”
“Say again?”
“Never mind.”
He found them in about ninety seconds, because they weren’t hiding. They were walking down the exact middle of Peachtree Street, in perfect step, the rope swinging between them like a jump rope at recess. The dog was in front, head high and tail going, carrying the rope like a diploma. The donkey followed one exact length of rope behind, unbothered, and every few steps he flicked an ear the way a rich man taps his cigar.
Colt pulled up alongside them and rolled down the window.
“Ma’am,” he said to the dog. Then he felt foolish, then he decided he didn’t, because there was nobody else to address.
Lulabelle glanced at him without slowing down. She had been chased off porches by better men.
“Ma’am, that donkey’s not yours.”
Lulabelle kept walking. So did Clarence. Colt rolled along beside them at two miles an hour with his blue lights going, feeling like the world’s slowest parade float. Behind the church, the Methodists were letting out. A row of people in good clothes stopped on the sidewalk to watch. Somebody started filming. Somebody else said, “Is that Odessa’s donkey?” and a third person said, “Lord, that’s Lulabelle,” with the weary affection of a whole town that has had its yard trash gone through by the same dog.
Miss Odessa Pruitt had been at the 11 o’clock service. She had come home, found her gate open and her donkey gone, and done what any woman of her generation would do. She grabbed the nearest heavy object, a CorningWare dish of chicken-and-rice casserole meant for the Hendersons’ new baby, and set off down Peachtree Street at a speed nobody thought her knees still had.
She caught up with the procession at the four-way stop.
“CLARENCE,” she said. It was not a shout. Miss Odessa had never needed to shout. It was a tone, and it had stopped two husbands, several grandsons, and once, famously, a Jehovah’s Witness in mid-sentence.
Clarence stopped.
Lulabelle, who had never heard that tone in her life, kept going until she reached the end of the rope. She turned around, offended.
Miss Odessa stood in the intersection in her Sunday hat, with the casserole held over her head like she was ready to throw it, which, everyone agreed later, she was.
“Where,” she said to the donkey, “do you think you are going?”
Clarence looked at her for a long moment. Then he looked down Peachtree Street toward the Dollar General, the feed store, the highway, and the whole wide world beyond the split-rail fence. Then, very slowly, he looked back at her.
He heaved a sigh so deep it rattled his halter.
“That’s what I thought,” said Miss Odessa.
Deputy Ramsey’s report, submitted at 1:47 p.m., ran two paragraphs. His sergeant later had it framed. It said the donkey had been “returned to the owner without incident,” that the dog was “known to the community,” and that no charges were being pursued “due to the suspect being a dog.” Under “Additional Notes,” Colt wrote, “Donkey appeared to be a willing participant,” and then he deleted it, and then he typed it back in, because it was true.
Miss Odessa walked Clarence home herself. Lulabelle trailed behind at a dignified distance, like an ex who hasn’t been invited to the wedding but has opinions about the cake. At the gate Miss Odessa turned around and looked at the dog for a long time.
Then she peeled the foil back on the casserole and set it on the ground.
“You might as well,” she said. “The Hendersons are getting a pound cake.”
Lulabelle ate the whole thing. Clarence watched over the fence, chewing on nothing.
The next morning, Dwayne Kittle saw Lulabelle go by on her usual route, past the church, past the four-way, all the way to the end of Peachtree. She stopped at the split-rail fence and sat down. On the other side, Clarence walked over and stood there.
They stayed like that for a while, the dog and the donkey, looking out at the road together.
The gate, everyone noticed, had a padlock on it now.
Lulabelle had already started working on it.
Stories are inspired by actual dispatch calls reported on CrimeRadar. Aside from the linked emergency services dispatch, the people and events described are fictitious.
Stories and illustrations were developed with the help of Grok, an AI assistant, and edited by the author.


Leave a Reply