
Based on a real dispatch call: Toddler stuck in pumpkin after photo shoot, Hannibal, NY, 3:53 PM EST, Wednesday, Nov 11, 2026.
By the second week of November, the farm stand on Route 3 had given up on pumpkins. The sign out front said EVERYTHING MUST GO, and under it, in smaller letters, PLEASE.
That’s where Kendra Vosburgh found the big one. It was orange and lopsided, about the size of a beanbag chair, and it had been sitting there since September, watching the smaller pumpkins leave one by one. It was marked down from forty dollars to six. The man at the stand waved goodbye to it, a little emotionally.
Kendra had a plan. Halloween was over, but the Christmas cards weren’t done, and the light in Hannibal on a November afternoon is a soft, golden thing that lasts about eleven minutes. Her sister Marnie had a real camera and a ring light and had once taken a class. They would carve out the top of the pumpkin, set Posey inside it in her little knit acorn hat, and get the photo that would make every cousin in Oswego County sick with envy.
Posey was a toddler. She was at the age where she had strong opinions about socks and none at all about danger. She looked at the pumpkin. The pumpkin looked at her.
“In,” said Posey, which was everybody’s first mistake.
The shoot went beautifully for about nine minutes.
Marnie lay on her stomach on the lawn on Mill Street, shouting, “Look at Aunt Marnie! Look at the birdie!” There was no birdie. Posey looked anyway. She smiled. She waved. She ate a Goldfish cracker with the dignity of a small duchess in a hot tub. Marnie took four hundred pictures.
Then Kendra reached in to lift her out, and Posey didn’t come.
It turns out a toddler goes into a pumpkin a lot easier than she comes out. Posey had settled. Her legs were folded. Her snowsuit had puffed up like a marshmallow in a microwave. The opening at the top, which Kendra had cut with a bread knife and a lot of confidence, was a good two inches narrower than it needed to be on the way out.
Kendra pulled gently. Posey stayed put.
“Okay,” said Kendra.
“Okay,” said Posey, cheerfully, and ate another Goldfish.
Grandpa Walt came out of the house in his slippers. He looked over the situation the way he looked over everything, as though it had been designed by somebody from Syracuse.
“Just bust it,” he said.
“We are not busting it,” said Kendra. “She’s in it.”
“I’ll bust it from the far side.”
“Dad, it doesn’t have a far side. It’s round.”
Marnie suggested butter. Walt suggested a hammer. Posey suggested more Goldfish, and that was the only idea that got approved.
So Kendra called for help.
The dispatcher at Oswego County 911 had been on since seven that morning. She listened to the whole story twice, and then she looked at the screen in front of her. There was no call type for “pumpkin.” There was no “photo shoot,” no “toddler, produce-related,” no “mother, embarrassed.”
She made a judgment call.
“Animal rescue, Mill Street,” she said into the radio. “Animal rescue, citizen assist.” Then, in the same calm voice: “Caller requesting assistance for a female stuck in a pumpkin after a photo shoot.”
Somewhere in Oswego County, two people in two vehicles looked at their radios at the same time.
Both units were there within about three minutes. The first one out of his truck was Lieutenant Gus Ostrander. In twenty-two years as a volunteer firefighter he had pulled a grown man out of a tube slide, but never a person out of produce. He walked over to the pumpkin, crouched down, and looked inside.
Posey looked back at him. She held out a Goldfish.
“Thank you, ma’am,” said Gus, and took it.
The second unit was Nate Brophy. He was twenty-four. He walked around the pumpkin twice, very slowly.
“Is it real?” he asked.
“It’s real,” said Kendra.
“I only ask because they make ceramic ones now.”
“It’s real, Nate.”
Walt raised his hammer to say a few words, and Gus raised one hand without looking, and Walt lowered the hammer. That’s twenty-two years of experience.
The solution, in the end, came out of the Dollar General bag in Kendra’s minivan. In it was a pumpkin carving kit she’d bought in October and forgotten about. Inside the kit was a little orange plastic saw, about four inches long, with teeth like a comb. It was the kind of saw they sell for eight-year-olds, because it can cut a pumpkin and nothing else.
Gus held it up. “Ma’am,” he said, “may I?”
He knelt in the grass and started cutting a door in the side of the pumpkin, nice and slow, nowhere near Posey. Nate held the flashlight. Marnie took pictures. It took eleven minutes, which happened to be just how long the golden light lasted.
When Gus pulled the door open, Posey crawled out onto the lawn on her own, stood up, brushed off her snowsuit, and turned around to admire the pumpkin. It looked like a little cottage now.
Then she pointed at it.
“In,” said Posey.
“No,” said three adults and two firefighters.
The Vosburgh family Christmas card went out in December. It’s not the picture of Posey smiling in the pumpkin. It’s the one Marnie took at the very end: a toddler in an acorn hat standing in front of a pumpkin with a door in it, holding hands with a fire lieutenant, while a younger man looks very hard at his flashlight and an old man in slippers holds a hammer in the background.
Across the bottom, it says SEASON’S GREETINGS FROM MILL STREET.
Gus has it on the fridge at the station.
Stories are inspired by actual dispatch calls reported on CrimeRadar. Aside from the linked emergency services dispatch, the people and events described are fictitious.
Stories and illustrations were developed with the help of Grok, an AI assistant, and edited by the author.


Leave a Reply